Should ND be a 4 seed?

[FSUKW]

Since they don’t have a CG. Another quality game they don’t have to play to risk a loss?

[JdPat04]

If people want conference champions as a qualifier then ND shouldn’t be allowed

[FSUKW]

That wasn’t the question but under current platform if 11-1 teams can get in, 12-0 is a no brainer.

I’m asking about seeding.

[JdPat04]

That wasn’t the question but under current platform if 11-1 teams can get in, 12-0 is a no brainer.

I’m asking about seeding.

Under the current platform yes. I was just making those thoughts clear.

As to the original not if they have a tough schedule overall.

[FSUKW]

That wasn’t the question but under current platform if 11-1 teams can get in, 12-0 is a no brainer.

I’m asking about seeding.

Under the current platform yes. I was just making those thoughts clear.

As to the original not if they have a tough schedule overall.

The big question is do you put a 1 loss team at #3 and an undefeated team at 4 given #3 played an extra game?

[JdPat04]

That wasn’t the question but under current platform if 11-1 teams can get in, 12-0 is a no brainer.

I’m asking about seeding.

Under the current platform yes. I was just making those thoughts clear.

As to the original not if they have a tough schedule overall.

The big question is do you put a 1 loss team at #3 and an undefeated team at 4 given #3 played an extra game?

Depends on the loss imo.


A loss to a good team and the rest wins, I’d put them over them probably.

A loss to a crap team? Nah.

Bama loses to UT or Arky this year? Fuck no. Put and over us.

OSU has one loss to Penn St or UM and not Purdue then they’d belong over ND. As of right now I wouldn’t have a problem with ND over osu.

If UGA beats us I think they should be over ND. The only real bad thing about their loss was how it happened, but it wasn’t to a shit team. They’ll be beating a better team than anybody else.

So honestly, I don’t think there are a set of rules which is what makes it complicated. Which this is seeding and not talking about qualifying, there should be more of a formula to it than there is to picking “the best 4 teams”

[FlatEarth]

However it works out. Whoever plays ND in the first game is basically benefiting from a bye week. So vastly overrated as the number 3 ranked team...

[JdPat04]

However it works out. Whoever plays ND in the first game is basically benefiting from a bye week. So vastly overrated as the number 3 ranked team...

It’s not bragging at Bama but just arguing against your point.

What team deserves #3?

Clemson barely squeaked by A&M & Cuse.

UGA got embarrassed by LSU who lost to Bama and UF and technically A&M but yeah.

ohsu? Nope

UCF? Sure

OU?

At the moment you haven’t earned higher than #4. Beat Alabama and then you have an argument.

[gatrnation1]

ND will be exposed again. Like they were in the NCG against bama. Barely beat USC last week. Beat UM that was pwned by Ohio last week. I want an 8 team playoff! :blowup

[bigbluebazooka]

ND will be exposed again. Like they were in the NCG against bama. Barely beat USC last week. Beat UM that was pwned by Ohio last week. I want an 8 team playoff! :blowup

If not 8, add two more and give 1 and 2 a bye week.

[JdPat04]

ND will be exposed again. Like they were in the NCG against bama. Barely beat USC last week. Beat UM that was pwned by Ohio last week. I want an 8 team playoff! :blowup

If not 8, add two more and give 1 and 2 a bye week.

Then you have non stop bitching because ohsu isn’t a #2

[CraigKressel]

They should not be allowed in period because the system is fucked for not being equal across the board. Join a fucking conference or get the fuck out.

[FSUKW]

They should not be allowed in period because the system is fucked for not being equal across the board. Join a fucking conference or get the fuck out.

What’s being a conference have to do with this?

BAMA got in at 11-1 last year. Notre Dame is 12-0.