Peyton Manning is the best football player in history

[semperfi4727]

Keep posting statistics YP. Please keep going :dog

Stats don't lie

You're right. For once. He has been the best player in the league 5 times. No one else has done it more than 3. He is the best. The stats back it up

Look at his post season stats and then come back

[ericberry14]

And YP every time you have to call me Erin in a post it just confirms how much better I am at this than you. You won't even understand what I'm saying though :(

[Y4NK33 PL4N3T]

Kareem has the most MVPs in NBA history - GOAT!

[semperfi4727]

Barry Bonds has won 7 NL MVP'S so by Erins logic he is the GOAT!

Many would consider him to be if he wasn't a cheater.... The best hitter anyway easily.
But he did cheat. If you took away his mvps from cheating then what?


Peyton didn't cheat. It's completely valid

How many rings does barry have :thought

[Y4NK33 PL4N3T]

And YP every time you have to call me Erin in a post it just confirms how much better I am at this than you. You won't even understand what I'm saying though :(

I don't have to, I choose to, because (a) it gets under your skin and (b) you cry like a girl a lot. :sadyes

[ericberry14]

And YP every time you have to call me Erin in a post it just confirms how much better I am at this than you. You won't even understand what I'm saying though :(

I don't have to, I choose to, because (a) it gets under your skin and (b) you cry like a girl a lot. :sadyes

:biglol does it? Could have fooled me seeing as how this is the only time I've ever brought it up :dog

[Y4NK33 PL4N3T]

And YP every time you have to call me Erin in a post it just confirms how much better I am at this than you. You won't even understand what I'm saying though :(

I don't have to, I choose to, because (a) it gets under your skin and (b) you cry like a girl a lot. :sadyes

:biglol does it? Could have fooled me seeing as how this is the only time I've ever brought it up :dog

No, it isn't. Not only are you lying now, you're deflecting again.

You're not good at this.

[semperfi4727]

And YP every time you have to call me Erin in a post it just confirms how much better I am at this than you. You won't even understand what I'm saying though :(

I don't have to, I choose to, because (a) it gets under your skin and (b) you cry like a girl a lot. :sadyes

Not fair on your second point because he cries about everything

[Y4NK33 PL4N3T]

And YP every time you have to call me Erin in a post it just confirms how much better I am at this than you. You won't even understand what I'm saying though :(

I don't have to, I choose to, because (a) it gets under your skin and (b) you cry like a girl a lot. :sadyes

Not fair on your second point because he cries about everything

You make a fair point. :thought

[ericberry14]

And YP every time you have to call me Erin in a post it just confirms how much better I am at this than you. You won't even understand what I'm saying though :(

I don't have to, I choose to, because (a) it gets under your skin and (b) you cry like a girl a lot. :sadyes

:biglol does it? Could have fooled me seeing as how this is the only time I've ever brought it up :dog

No, it isn't. Not only are you lying now, you're deflecting again.

You're not good at this.

Link? Because it is. Jd brought it up the other time. Because you do it so often. Does not bother me... Makes me laugh a bit :)

[Y4NK33 PL4N3T]

And YP every time you have to call me Erin in a post it just confirms how much better I am at this than you. You won't even understand what I'm saying though :(

I don't have to, I choose to, because (a) it gets under your skin and (b) you cry like a girl a lot. :sadyes

:biglol does it? Could have fooled me seeing as how this is the only time I've ever brought it up :dog

No, it isn't. Not only are you lying now, you're deflecting again.

You're not good at this.

Link? Because it is. Jd brought it up the other time. Because you do it so often. Does not bother me... Makes me laugh a bit :)

Then laugh. :dunno

Ready to address Peyton's failure in the post season? Or are we going to talk about the Patriots again :dog

[semperfi4727]

And YP every time you have to call me Erin in a post it just confirms how much better I am at this than you. You won't even understand what I'm saying though :(

I don't have to, I choose to, because (a) it gets under your skin and (b) you cry like a girl a lot. :sadyes

:biglol does it? Could have fooled me seeing as how this is the only time I've ever brought it up :dog

No, it isn't. Not only are you lying now, you're deflecting again.

You're not good at this.

Link? Because it is. Jd brought it up the other time. Because you do it so often. Does not bother me... Makes me laugh a bit :)

No offense, you've deflected many times in this thread alone, and since when has jd's opinion mattered

[ericberry14]

Why are we talking about deflecting? Can we please drop that shit... I'm saying I have never brought him calling me Erin up constantly and he said I did. I asked for link. No need to get into anything else right now

[ericberry14]

And YP every time you have to call me Erin in a post it just confirms how much better I am at this than you. You won't even understand what I'm saying though :(

I don't have to, I choose to, because (a) it gets under your skin and (b) you cry like a girl a lot. :sadyes

:biglol does it? Could have fooled me seeing as how this is the only time I've ever brought it up :dog

No, it isn't. Not only are you lying now, you're deflecting again.

You're not good at this.

Link? Because it is. Jd brought it up the other time. Because you do it so often. Does not bother me... Makes me laugh a bit :)

Then laugh. :dunno

Ready to address Peyton's failure in the post season? Or are we going to talk about the Patriots again :dog

Why?

[semperfi4727]

QBs better than manning

There's Brady
Rodgers
Montana
Young
Marino
Staubach
Unitas (he's not even the best QB to ever play for the colts)

[MIAMIDOMINATION]

Eb

None of us are saying manning isnt one of the greatest

We are just saying its not nearly as clear cut that hes the goat as you say it is

[MIAMIDOMINATION]

QBs better than manning

There's Brady
Rodgers
Montana
Young
Marino
Staubach
Unitas (he's not even the best QB to ever play for the colts)

I disagree

Montana
Elway
Marino
brady
Manning
kelly
Young
Moon
Favre
Rodgers

[semperfi4727]

Eb

None of us are saying manning isnt one of the greatest

We are just saying its not nearly as clear cut that hes the goat as you say it is

I'm saying he isn't one of the greatest. You could even throw elway on my previous post's list

[Y4NK33 PL4N3T]

[
Then laugh. :dunno

Ready to address Peyton's failure in the post season? Or are we going to talk about the Patriots again :dog

Why?

The fact that you ask 'Why?' you should address/discuss a playoffs post season performance is really the problem, it's clear you do not understand so I'll try and explain it to you.

When you want to make a case for GOAT you have to understand what it means to be 'great' wrt to pro athletes.

The great athletes have always been exceptional in the regular season (Peyton,Jeff George, Lebron James before the cHeat move), the greatest athletes have always been those who can perform in the post season/playoffs when the pressure is the highest and championships are on the line (Brady, Jeter, Jordan etc).

Greatness is forever intertwined with winning titles, since that is the goal of every sport. The more titles you win, the greater the argument for said player.

Does the player have to be flawless in the post season? No. Brady has lost Super Bowls, Mariano Rivera choked World Series, but both have won more titles than they have lost.

The same can't be said for Peyton. His playoff record is sub .500, he has 24 INTS in 23 games - that's shitty, hence he's back of the line.

[semperfi4727]

QBs better than manning

There's Brady
Rodgers
Montana
Young
Marino
Staubach
Unitas (he's not even the best QB to ever play for the colts)

I disagree

Montana
Elway
Marino
brady
Manning
kelly
Young
Moon
Favre
Rodgers

Rodgers will be, but that's speculation at this point. But I count some of the older QBs because the rules were harder for passing than they are today. Staubach, Unitas, Young, moon meant more to their teams than manning does to the broncos. Nb4 eb takes that as saying I don't think manning means shit to the broncos, I'm just saying the broncos have the best squad in the nfl